McCallion and McCallion Realty

We’re not your typical real estate company.

That’s what you’ll discover with McCallion & McCallion — among the top real estate producers on Sanibel and Captiva Islands these past three years. ★ Led by Susan and Jim McCallion, the McCallion & McCallion team brings you comprehensive, effective real estate sales and marketing acumen — complemented by an extensive network of motivated island-lovers looking to buy or sell. ★ Most importantly, Susan and Jim live on and love these islands — and will bring their passion, knowledge, market understanding, objectivity, honesty and true commitment to your satisfaction. That’s what we mean by “realty done right.”
INTERESTED? LET’S SHARE COFFEE TODAY.

We stand firmly behind our promises.

If you are looking to BUY:

Love Guarantee Reverse Rounded

If you are looking to SELL:

Sold at your price guaranteed or we'll pay you $5000

Don’t search for homes on your own when you can have the experts on your side. We’re happy to help, even if you are just browsing. We provide you with:

  • first hand knowledge of most properties for sale
  • more up-to-date and accurate than Zillow or other nationwide sites
  • expert negotiation experience so you don’t overpay

Our unique Buyers In Waiting program places your home in front of more buyers than other Realtors can by leveraging:

  • our proprietary database of 1000’s of island buyers waiting for the right property
  • The best internet marketing skills in our region - 95% of buyers use the internet to search homes
  • We guarantee our performance!

Please call us at (239) 472-1950 and ask us about our guarantee programs!

Everyone here plays on the same team, YOUR Team.

Sure we’re a smaller, boutique firm, but unlike the big brokers where most agents work for themselves, everyone at McCallion & McCallion is working for you.

Each of us can focus on our unique talents, bringing you a team of experts, instead of a single, overworked, jack-of-all-trades agent. Click here to contact us.

Susan McCallion

Co-Owner, Broker
"The Negotiator"

Jim McCallion

Co-Owner, Marketing & Luxury Properties
"Marketing Megaphone"

Denny Chan

Client Care Coordinator
"Home Search Initializer"

Trish Nichols

Client Care Coordinator
"Director of Smiles"

Tiffany Mills

Marketing Coordinator
"Marketing Ninja Warrior"

Anna Turner

Sales Partner
"Home Match Maker"

Joe Ziccardi

Sales Partner
"Jersey JoeZ"

Robin Suslick

Sales Partner
"Rockin' Robin"

Dale Suslick

Sales Partner
"The Regulator"

Patty Holston

Sales Partner
"Transition Specialist"

Kimberly Ann Chaps-Louchart

Sales Partner
"Savvy Investor"

Elise Porter-Dean

Sales Partner
"House Hunter"

Read what our clients say.

Click to see more testimonials...

Visit our centrally located Sanibel office.

Below are some of our recent sales.

1511-Angel-Dr-Sanibel-Just-Sold2
3/3 | 2,198 Living SqFt. | $1,250,000 -1511 Angel Drive
2142-Egret-Cir-Sanibel-Sold-0
3/2 | 1,800 Living SqFt. | $485,000 -2142 Egret Circle
827-E-Gulf-Dr-Unit-J6-Sanibel-justsold
2/2 | 967 Living SqFt. | $485,000 -827 E Gulf Dr UNIT J6
12640-Kelly-Palm-Drive-WEB-1
3/2 | 1,862 Living SqFt. | $369,00012640 Kelly Palm Drive
3238-tennis-villas-captiva-fl-4
2/2 | 894 Living SqFt. | $410,000 -3238 Tennis Villas
sundial-p401-4
2/2 | 1,516 Living SqFt. | $852,000 -1401 Middle Gulf Drive, P401
615-hideaway-court-sanibel-fl
3/3 | 2,870 Living SqFt. | $1,160,000 -615 Hideaway Court
11700-pasetto-lane-104-fort-myers
3/2 | 1,523 Living SqFt. | $165,500 -11700 Pasetto Lane, Unit 104
845-e-gulf-drive-sanibel-sold-full
2/2 | 921 Living SqFt. | $422,500 -845 E Gulf Drive, Unit 822
760-windlass-way-sanibel-sold-edits
3/3 | 2,238 Living SqFt. | $924,000 -760 Windlass Way
sandollar-c101-sold
2/2 | 1,304 Living SqFt. | $837,500 -1795 Middle Gulf Drive, Unit C101
739-Pyrula-Ave-Sanibel-FL-1
3/3 | 2,360 Living SqFt. | $1,050,000 -739 Pyrula Ave
Click to see more of our sales...