• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
(239) 472-1950 Login
Sanibel Real Estate Guide Logo

Sanibel Real Estate Guide

Find your Sanibel Home and Learn About Life on Our Island

  • Find Your Home
    • Real Estate Search
    • Island Condo Guide
    • Sanibel Map Search
  • Island Info
    • Island Living
    • Real Estate News
    • Sanibel & Captiva Market Report
    • Owning Vacation Rentals
    • Retiring On Sanibel
    • Sanibel New Resident Guide
  • About
    • Who We Are
  • Contact Us
  • Show Search
Hide Search
McCallion and McCallion Realty

About McCallion & McCallion Realty

We’re not your typical real estate company.

That’s what you’ll discover with McCallion & McCallion — among the top real estate producers on Sanibel and Captiva Islands these past three years. ★ Led by Susan and Jim McCallion, the McCallion & McCallion team brings you comprehensive, effective real estate sales and marketing acumen — complemented by an extensive network of motivated island-lovers looking to buy or sell luxury property. ★ Most importantly, Susan and Jim live on and love these islands — and will bring their passion, knowledge, market understanding, objectivity, honesty and true commitment to your satisfaction. That’s what we mean by “realty done right.”
INTERESTED? LET’S SHARE COFFEE TODAY.

About McCallion and McCallion VideoPlay Video

Everyone here plays on the same team, YOUR Team.

Sure we’re a smaller, boutique firm, but unlike the big brokers where most agents work for themselves, everyone at McCallion & McCallion is working for you.

Each of us can focus on our unique talents, bringing you a team of experts, instead of a single, overworked, jack-of-all-trades agent. Click here to contact us.

Susan McCallion Realtor

Susan McCallion

Co-Founder, Broker
"The Negotiator"

Jim McCallion

Jim McCallion

Co-Founder, Marketing Director
"Marketing Megaphone"

Patty-Holston-400x400

Patty Holston

Sales Partner
"Relocation Specialist"

Yvette Pryor

Yvette Pryor

Sales Partner
"Retired Navy"

Carrie Prather

Carrie Prather

Sales Partner
"Real Estate Nurse"

Milissa Sprecher portrait

Milissa Sprecher

Sales Partner
"Capturing The Moment"

Paul Primeaux

Paul Primeaux

Sales Partner
"Master Captain"

Jackson Sprecher portrait

Jackson Sprecher

Sales Partner
"Landing Your Dream Home"

Denny Chan

Denny Chan

Client Care Coordinator
"Home Search Initializer"

Elizabeth Craig

Elizabeth Craig

Broker's Assistant
"Susan's Right-Hand"

Jan Kath

Jan Kath

Transaction Coordinator
"Director of Details"

Read what our clients say.

We are thrilled with the sale of our house. The house had been on the market for six months. It came close to a sale a few times, but the deals fell through. It is tough to sell a house from a distance. We switched over to McCallion and McCallion. They recommended that we make a few, rather inexpensive changes to the property and brought in a professional photographer to highlight the features of the house. Someone from the company was on the property to make sure the changes were made promptly and to their satisfaction. We received three offers on the house the day it went back on the market with one of those offers at our asking price! We closed 30 days later. Thank you, Susan, Jim, Machelle, and Matthew. We could not be happier with McCallion and McCallion!

Robert S.

Sanibel, FL

August 2, 2023

Kate on the McCallion team was super responsive and knowledgeable. She did not hesitate to enthusiastically assist with any issue that we encountered in the sale of our Fort Myers condo. We highly recommend Kate and look forward to working with her in the future.

Leslie & Paul

Fort Myers, FL

January 22, 2022

There are tons of realtors out there and who you work with matters. Jacob is hands down the best realtor we have ever worked with. He is very professional, knowledgeable, passionate, and dedicated to delivering the best service around. Thank you for making our dreams come true Jacob!

Jarret J.

Fort Myers, FL

November 15, 2021

Susan McCallion and her team were awesome with helping us sell our Sanibel home. They’re knowledgeable, hard-working, and even fun to work with! Even our dog loves the McCallion Team and they helped us watch him in a pinch! We recommend Susan to all of our friends on Sanibel.

Deb & Greg

Sanibel, FL

May 15, 2021

Patient, pleasant, and professional best sums it up. When we purchased our first Sanibel home in 2011, we worked with Susan and the McCallion Realty team. Recently, we decided to upgrade our Sanibel property and we knew who to call! Susan sent us relevant listings of Sanibel homes for sale for more than a year. She offered candid advice on the best opportunities and ultimately helped us purchase the perfect one for us. Now, we’re using McCallion and McCallion to sell our original Sanibel property.

Lisa & Todd

Indianapolis, IN

February 2, 2021

Anna Turner was beyond excellent in helping us find our Sanibel dream home. Anna has comprehensive knowledge of the area and the local real estate market. She was a superb listener, extremely patient, great with communication, and just an overall pleasure to work with. Anna’s without question, the best real estate agent we’ve ever seen – and we’ve done a number of real estate transactions in the past!

Dawn & Les

Washington, MO

January 13, 2021

Click to see more testimonials...

(We're proud of the them!)

Visit our centrally located Sanibel office.

McCallion and McCallion Realty Sanibel LocationView on Google Maps
McCallion and McCallion Realty Office
McCallion and McCallion Realty

McCallion & McCallion Realty
1640 Periwinkle Way, Suite #1 Sanibel Island, FL 33957

(239) 472-1950

Here are properties we currently have for sale.

1501 Middle Gulf Dr UNIT C207
1501 Middle Gulf Dr, Unit C207
Sundial West
845 E Gulf Dr, 822
Sanibel Moorings
845 E Gulf Dr #741
845 E Gulf Dr #741
Sanibel Moorings
805 E Gulf Dr #E2 Sanibel, FL 33957
805 E Gulf Drive, E2
Sanibel Arms
12640 Kelly Palm Dr, Fort Myers, FL
12640 Kelly Palm Dr.
Kelly Greens
5842 Crabwood CT
5842 Crabwood CT
Fort Myers
14344 Harbour Links Ct #5B
Gulf Harbour
2737 W Gulf Dr UNIT 122
2737 W Gulf Dr, Unit 122
Sand Pointe Condos
1341 Middle Gulf Dr UNIT 15B, Sanibel
1341 Middle Gulf Drive #15B
Sunset South
5414 Osprey Court, Sanibel
5414 Osprey Court
Heron's Landing
Blind Pass D204
5117 Sea Bell Rd #D204
Blind Pass
1662 DixieBeach Blvd
1662 Dixie Beach Blvd.
Dixie Beach
697 Spartina Court Sanibel
697 Spartina Court
Sea Oats
421 Lake Murex Circle
421 Lake Murex Circle
Lake Murex
12481 Barrington Court, Fort Myers
12481 Barrington Court
McGregor Woods
1113 Sand Castle Rd, Sanibel
1113 Sand Castle Rd
Sanibel Dunes
1524 Wilton Lane, Sanibel
1524 Wilton Lane
Gumbo Limbo
805 E Gulf Drive, D7
805 E Gulf Drive, D7
Sanibel Arms
5117 Sea Bell Rd C201
5117 Sea Bell Rd C201
Blind Pass
Wooster
2320 Wooster Lane #3
Lake Palms
9778 Country Oaks Drive, Fort Myes
9778 Country Oaks Drive
Fort Myers
16260 Kelly Cove Dr, #238
16260 Kelly Cove Dr, #238
Kelly Greens
6068 Dinkins Lake Road, Sanibel
6068 Dinkins Lake Road
Vacant Lot

Below are some of our recent sales.

3/2 | 1,364 Living SqFt. | 970000
1376 Sand Castle Rd
5305 Umbrella Pool Road, Sanibel
3/2.5 | 2,256 Living SqFt. |
5303 Umbrella Pool Rd
4428 Waters Edge Lane, Sanibel
3/3 | 2,288 Living SqFt. | 1675000
4428 Waters Edge Ln
Loggerhead Cay 181
2/2 | 1,184 Living SqFt. |
979 E Gulf Drive, Unit 181
2239 Starfish Lane, Sanibel
3/3 | 2,572 Living SqFt. |
2239 Starfish Lane
845 East Gulf Drive #612
2/2 | 912 Living SqFt. |
845 East Gulf Dr. #612
3049 W Gulf Dr 302, Sanibel
3/3 | 2,540 Living Sqft. | $1,800,000
3049 W Gulf Dr, Unit 302
976 Sand Castle Rd, Sanibel
3/3 | 1,698 Living SqFt. | $859,000
976 Sand Castle Rd
1270 Par View Drive, Sanibel
3/2 | 2,067 Living SqFt | $750,000
1270 Par View Drive
658 Donax Street
3/2 | 1,519 Living SqFt. | $699,000
658 Donax Street
12334 Oak Brook Ct
4/2.5 | 3,648 Living SqFt. | $875,000
12334 Oak Brook Ct
9421 Moonlight Drive, Sanibel
3/2 | 2,453 Living Sqft. | $625,000
9421 Moonlight Drive
Click to see more of our sales...

(in case you're curious)

More real estate resources

  • Sanibel Real Estate: Retirement Guide
  • The Ultimate Sanibel Boating Safety Guide
  • Sanibel's Boat Safety Guidebook for Kids!
  • Homeowners Guide to Energy Efficiency
  • Emergency Preparedness
  • Guide to Recycling
  • Real Estate Basics: What You Need To Know When Buying A Home

Explore more

McCallion & McCallion Realty Logo

McCallion & McCallion Realty
1640 Periwinkle Way, Suite 1
Sanibel Island, Florida 33957
(239) 472-1950

  • email us
  • facebook
  • instagram
  • pinterest
McCallion & McCallion Realty Logo
(239) 472-1950 email us facebook instagram pinterest
Copyright © · Susan McCallion · Broker · McCallion & McCallion · Sanibel Real Estate · Listings · Sitemap