• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
(239) 472-1950 Login
Sanibel Real Estate Guide Logo

Sanibel Real Estate Guide

Find your Sanibel Home and Learn About Life on Our Island

  • Find Your Home
    • Real Estate Search
    • Island Condo Guide
    • Sanibel Map Search
  • Island Info
    • Island Living
    • Real Estate News
    • Sanibel & Captiva Market Report
    • Owning Vacation Rentals
    • Retiring On Sanibel
    • Sanibel New Resident Guide
  • About
    • Who We Are
  • Contact Us
  • Show Search
Hide Search
Home/Real Estate News/Selling Secret: Price Your Home UNDER Market Value

Selling Secret: Price Your Home UNDER Market Value

That’s not a typo. If you want to sell your home, pricing your home just under market value can earn you a higher final sales price on your property. Most homeowner’s think the opposite. They price their property just over the market value, so there is room for negotiation. While this is a logical way of thinking, lets look at how this typically plays out. 

1846-Ardsley-Way-Sanibel-MLS-pool

Scenario 1: Pricing Over Market Value

A house that is worth $800k at market value, is listed at $850k to allow room for negotiation. Those who are searching for homes up to $800k, will not even see this listing in their search parameters. Therefore, you are missing the audience most likely to purchase your home! Sell My Home Fast Raleigh can help by strategically pricing your property to attract the right buyers.

Those who are searching for homes up to $900k will see your listing, along with the other homes whose true market value is between $850k-900k. How do you think your $800k home stacks up compared to a home whose actual market value is $100k higher? These prospective buyers will likely flip through a few photos of your property, make a mental note that the price is too high for the value, and move on.

The result? Your home might sit on the market for a season or two until the right buyer comes along, sees the potential, and offers you $775k as a starting point. Maybe you’ll end up agreeing on a final sales price of $800k when it’s all said and done, however long that takes. To help showcase your home in the best light, hiring a professional Real Estate Photographer
can make a significant difference.

To avoid this lengthy process, it’s crucial to start with an accurate price from the beginning. The key is ensuring your listing aligns closely with what potential buyers are actually willing to pay. An inflated price can deter interested buyers before they even step foot in the door. By obtaining a proper valuation, you can make sure you’re listing at a price that reflects your home’s true worth, without scaring away buyers who might otherwise be interested.

If you’re uncertain about where to set your price, it’s a smart idea to get a professional opinion. Checking out a reliable home valuation service, such as Treasure Davis, can help you get a better idea of where your home stands in today’s market. With an accurate valuation, you can confidently list your home at a price that attracts the right buyers, increasing your chances of selling quickly and for the right price.

Scenario 2: Pricing Under Market Value

Let’s take the same scenario and price the home at $799k instead of $850k. Now, your property will be at the top of the page when viewing a list of homes for sale under $800k. And guess what, it will be the best looking home in that price range, since you’re now competing with homes that might be overpriced with a true market value of $700k-750k.

Buyers now see your home as “a great value,” and there’s a chance it may receive more than one offer in a short amount of time. Especially when the market is hot and inventory is low, you will attract a number of interested buyers and agents wanting to come see your home in person as soon as possible.

I’m not making this up, take a peak at the pyramid below from NAR, which shows how the visibility of a listing changes when priced above and below market value. 

UP577E3CED0D3844

The result? Your home is of high demand, and could receive an offer in a very short amount of time. Depending on the market, you might even receive more than one offer, thus pushing your sales price ABOVE market value. But even if you only receive one offer, the demand of the property allows you to stick close to your list price of $799k, without having to negotiate down on price.

Of course, it does not work this way for every property here on the islands. But I use this example to show you a different strategy for pricing your Sanibel home. The most important key to the equation that I haven’t mentioned is understanding the true market value of your home. That’s where you enlist the help of an experience Realtor® who can research the recent sales data, look at your property in detail, and compare it to the current market conditions in order to assess a fair market value for your home.

Written by: Susan McCallion

Filed Under: Home Selling, Real Estate News

About Susan McCallion

Susan was exposed to real estate while young with her parent's 8 Re/MAX offices in Connecticut! In 2008, Susan and Jim became permanent Sanibel residents, starting McCallion & McCallion to bring a fresh approach to real estate.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Sanibel Real Estate News

Sanibel Population Per Mile of Beach Chart

Like Crowded Beaches? Don’t Come to Sanibel.…

Protected Nature = Protected Home Owner…

Heat Pump Installation: How It Affects Your Home’s Plumbing…

Florida Home Inventory Increases Significantly…

All About Coconut Palms…

424 E Gulf Drive

Sanibel Single Family Home Rental Restrictions…

New Captiva and Sanibel Real Estate Listings

View recent Captiva and Sanibel listings...

Sanibel Real Estate Listings

Sanibel Homes for sale

  • All Sanibel Homes for Sale
  • Sanibel Beachfront homes
  • Sanibel Bayfront homes
  • Sanibel Gulf Access homes
  • Sanibel Water View homes
  • Sanibel Elevated homes
  • Sanibel Golf Community homes

Sanibel Homes by Price

  • under $1,000,000
  • $1,000,000 - $1,500,000
  • $1,500,000 - $2,000,000
  • $2,000,000 - $3,000,000
  • $3,000,000 and up

Sanibel Condos for sale

  • --> See our full Sanibel Condo Guide
  • Sanibel Beachfront condos
  • Sanibel Bayfront condos
  • Sanibel Pet Friendly condos
  • Sanibel Boat Dock condos
  • Sanibel Condo Directory

Captiva Homes for Sale

  • Captiva Beachfront homes
  • Captiva Bayfront homes
  • Captiva Gulf Front condos
  • Captiva Bay View condos
  • under $4,000,000
  • $4,000,000 and up

Market Report

Featured Homes

1501 Middle Gulf Dr UNIT C207
1501 Middle Gulf Dr, Unit C207

Quick Home Search

Let me help you find a home,

while you learn about life on our island.

Home & Condo Search

Find My Home (more options...)

Map Search

Sanibel Island Real Estate

Purchasing Sanibel Island real estate is an investment in a unique and special community, unmatched elsewhere in Florida. Sanibel is a popular resort island famous for its beaches, shelling, and wildlife refuges. Over half of Sanibel Island is protected conservation land and wildlife refuges. Sanibel Island is home to the Sanibel Historical Village, BIG ARTS, Herb Strauss Theater and a variety of other museums and cultural activities.

Join Our Sanibel Real Estate Newsletter

Get new listings, foreclosures, island deal alerts, and Sanibel and Captiva real estate news.

Or click here to Contact Me.

People visit Sanibel Island for our beaches and shelling. Folks fall in love with Sanibel Island for our pristine natural beauty and friendly community. People buy Sanibel Island real estate to own a bit of what Florida should have been, now protected on Sanibel Island like no other Florida beach community.

Popular Features

Sanibel Condo Directory
Sanibel Condos for Sale
Be a Vacation Landlord
Sanibel Ranked #1 by Frommer
Sanibel Island Weather

The Sanibel Real Estate Guide will help you find Sanibel homes for sale or Captiva homes for sale that best suite your lifestyle, whether they be waterfront property, Island homes, canal front homes, Gulf front homes, bay front homes, oceanfront condos, bayfront condos, golf course communities, lots and home sites, Sanibel short sales, Sanibel foreclosures or, of course, commercial real estate on Sanibel or Captiva. In addition to Sanibel Island real estate listings, our site provides information about life on Sanibel, investing in Sanibel Island real estate, raising kids on Sanibel and Captiva, relocating to Sanibel Island, real estate market information, real estate statistics and blog posts

Don't let our website name "Sanibel Real Estate Guide" fool you. You'll find Captiva real estate too. Captiva Island boasts a vibrant community in paradise with golfing, boating and beach fun. See information and links about Marinas and Golf & Tennis Clubs on Sanibel and Captiva. Looking for off-Island, Southwest Florida real estate, you can easily search our MLS listings to find homes in a variety of zip codes and cities within Southwest Florida. If you'd like to speak to a live person, give me a call or e-mail - I'm always happy to help.

Featured Sanibel and Captiva Homes for Sale

1501 Middle Gulf Dr UNIT C207
1501 Middle Gulf Dr, Unit C207
Sundial West
845 E Gulf Dr, 822
Sanibel Moorings
845 E Gulf Dr #741
845 E Gulf Dr #741
Sanibel Moorings
805 E Gulf Dr #E2 Sanibel, FL 33957
805 E Gulf Drive, E2
Sanibel Arms
12640 Kelly Palm Dr, Fort Myers, FL
12640 Kelly Palm Dr.
Kelly Greens
5842 Crabwood CT
5842 Crabwood CT
Fort Myers
14344 Harbour Links Ct #5B
Gulf Harbour
2737 W Gulf Dr UNIT 122
2737 W Gulf Dr, Unit 122
Sand Pointe Condos
1341 Middle Gulf Dr UNIT 15B, Sanibel
1341 Middle Gulf Drive #15B
Sunset South
5414 Osprey Court, Sanibel
5414 Osprey Court
Heron's Landing
Blind Pass D204
5117 Sea Bell Rd #D204
Blind Pass
1662 DixieBeach Blvd
1662 Dixie Beach Blvd.
Dixie Beach
697 Spartina Court Sanibel
697 Spartina Court
Sea Oats
421 Lake Murex Circle
421 Lake Murex Circle
Lake Murex
12481 Barrington Court, Fort Myers
12481 Barrington Court
McGregor Woods
1113 Sand Castle Rd, Sanibel
1113 Sand Castle Rd
Sanibel Dunes
1524 Wilton Lane, Sanibel
1524 Wilton Lane
Gumbo Limbo
805 E Gulf Drive, D7
805 E Gulf Drive, D7
Sanibel Arms
5117 Sea Bell Rd C201
5117 Sea Bell Rd C201
Blind Pass
Wooster
2320 Wooster Lane #3
Lake Palms
9778 Country Oaks Drive, Fort Myes
9778 Country Oaks Drive
Fort Myers
16260 Kelly Cove Dr, #238
16260 Kelly Cove Dr, #238
Kelly Greens
6068 Dinkins Lake Road, Sanibel
6068 Dinkins Lake Road
Vacant Lot

Explore more

McCallion & McCallion Realty Logo

McCallion & McCallion Realty
1640 Periwinkle Way, Suite 1
Sanibel Island, Florida 33957
(239) 472-1950

  • email us
  • facebook
  • instagram
  • pinterest
McCallion & McCallion Realty Logo
(239) 472-1950 email us facebook instagram pinterest
Copyright © · Susan McCallion · Broker · McCallion & McCallion · Sanibel Real Estate · Listings · Sitemap